Whether you are teaching a lower elementary class, an upper elementary class, or the full span that includes both lower and upper elementary, it can often be the case that there is only a small group (or even maybe just one or two!) of older children in your class.
Follow the Trillium Montessori Talks podcast
Parents often enjoy a mixed-age classroom when their child is the youngest because they see that this is where the greatest benefit lies. Whenever there is a small handful of young students and a large amount of older students, parents of the youngest often see it as a HUGE bonus to have so many older children to be mentors and role models to their children. They envision the class offers a more significant challenge to all students, which their young child will benefit from. They also expect the older children to take them under their wing and teach them things.
Although there are sometimes, and in some instances, when parents see having older children in the class as a disadvantage, such as when older children bring new “colorful” language into the younger children’s awareness or otherwise expose them to experiences they weren’t ready for their children to be a part of, it is generally the case that parents see being the youngest as an advantage.
What many parents often overlook is the powerful educational benefits of having older children teach younger peers. Research has repeatedly demonstrated that teaching is one of the most effective ways to learn and retain information. By giving older students the opportunity to present the information or skills they have learned to a younger peer, they are able to reinforce their own understanding and solidify their knowledge. This process also allows for the development of important skills, such as:
An Opportunity for Leadership
Children who are the eldest in the classroom have the opportunity to be leaders. They are sought for advice, help, and for support, in instructional areas as well as in the social and emotional realm. The beauty of a mixed-age classroom is that children get the opportunity to first be the followers, who learn the ropes from others. Then they eventually grow in confidence as they have a year or two under their belt, and then they get to eventually be among the oldest in the class. This is when all of the learning crystallizes.
Inhibiting Behavior
In a mixed age group, the older children have more opportunities to practice inhibiting behavior that would negatively impact younger children. They develop an awareness of impressionable younger children and are more careful about speech and actions than they might otherwise be in a single-grade class.
Refinement of Communication and Presentation Skills
When children have an opportunity to tell a story or explain a procedure to another child, they are more likely to introduce relevant information in a simple, easy-to-understand language closer to their developmental level than when a teacher explains something. Of course, it’s important to value the teacher’s role in introducing rich vocabulary and complex skills in a way that a slightly older peer cannot, but that slightly older peer is a desirable choice because they will start with basic, big-picture knowledge, and the teacher can later fill in the details and nuance.
Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving Skills
When teaching their peers, older students must critically analyze the information they have learned and identify the most effective way to present it. This process not only strengthens their critical thinking and problem-solving skills but also helps them develop a deeper understanding of the material. By presenting the information in their own words, older students are forced to engage with the material at a higher level, making them more likely to remember it in the long term. Additionally, by working through the challenges of presenting information to a younger audience, older students are able to develop their ability to think creatively and find solutions to problems.
Increased Patience
It takes patience to wait for less skilled people to catch up to where we are, and so it’s no surprise that it is an exercise in patience to wait for a younger child to finish their thought, or to listen as their thoughts derail into a story that needs to be brought back to the center. The older child must be able to understand and respond to the needs of their audience and adjust their teaching style accordingly.
Increased Empathy
Children who reside in a community with other children have greater opportunities to develop a sense of empathy. Young children are more apt to wear their hearts on their sleeves, and freely share thoughts and emotions that older children may feel more guarded about expressing. This younger innocence can lend itself to the entire community being more openhearted. Also, older children can read to younger ones, help them get a band-aid when they fall, help them resolve disputes among same-age friends, help them spell a word they are grappling with, and more.
These spontaneous, organic experiences that happen within the context of an environment of choice, combined with the scaffolding that teachers offer during community gatherings, lend themselves to increased empathy amongst older children in a mixed-age classroom.
Departing Before the Leadership Year is a Missed Opportunity
Because parents aren’t often aware of the numerous advantages to being the eldest in a classroom, many will be conflicted about re-enrolling their children as they move towards that leadership year. This is unfortunate, as it not only leaves the classroom without a robust and balanced range of ages within the community, but it also deprives the child who leaves the experience of being one of those oldest children.
What a gift to not only come into an elementary classroom and have the opportunity to see where you are going but to also have the opportunity to see just how far you’ve come. Looking back at the entirety of Cosmic Education, and having a sense of one’s place in the universe, happens as the children grow and they look back and survey the land for all that they’ve done.
It is important to educate parents about the advantages of having their child in a multi-age setting, especially if they are considering moving them to a different school. Highlighting the leadership opportunities and personal growth that come from being one of the oldest students in the classroom can help retain these students and ensure they don’t miss out on the benefits of this learning environment. Consider organizing a parent education session to emphasize the value of staying for the “leadership year” and address any concerns they may have.
Strategies for Meeting the Unique Needs of a Small Group of Older Children in Your Classroom
Remembering that children have unique perspectives and experiences is crucial for creating a supportive and inclusive classroom environment. As a teacher, it’s important to understand that the dynamics of the classroom can have a significant impact on each student’s experience. Some older students may prefer the company of their peers, while others may feel empowered and confident being one of the oldest in the classroom.
When dealing with a small group of older children, it’s important to consider the individual needs and interests of each child. To create a positive learning experience, you can offer opportunities for special projects, hands-on activities, or lead roles in group activities that cater to their maturity level. Additionally, you can personalize lessons according to each student’s strengths and interests. For example, a younger student might complete a basic task such as writing a sentence and drawing an illustration, while an older student might be challenged to write a paragraph or composition or create a larger project such as a diorama or timeline. Finally, providing access to advanced resources and materials will give the child the opportunity they need to advance beyond what the environment currently offers. The goal is to create an environment where all students feel valued and challenged, regardless of their age or ability level.
Final Thoughts
As a teacher in a mixed-age classroom, it’s crucial to examine your own assumptions and biases to ensure that you believe in yourself and your ability to provide for a small group of older children. While there may be challenges for these students in a mixed-age setting, it’s important to remember that a complete Montessori environment should offer a wealth of opportunities for elementary students of any age. With a focus on personalized lessons and activities, you can confidently support your small group of older children and help them thrive. Whether it’s through reading, writing, or research, there are always ways to challenge and engage them beyond grade-level expectations.
To teach is to learn twice. –Joseph Joubert